Leave a Message

By providing your contact information to Lighthouse Realty, your personal information will be processed in accordance with Lighthouse Realty's Privacy Policy. By checking the box(es) below, you expressly consent to receive marketing or promotional real estate communication from Lighthouse Realty in the manner selected by you. For SMS text messages, message frequency varies. Message and data rates may apply. Consent is not a condition of purchase of any goods or services. You may opt out of receiving further communications from Lighthouse Realty at any time. To opt out of receiving SMS text messages, reply STOP to unsubscribe. SMS text messaging is subject to our Terms of Use.

Thank you for your message. We will be in touch with you shortly.

5460 4TH ST
5460 4TH ST
5460 4TH ST
5460 4TH ST
5460 4TH ST
5460 4TH ST
5460 4TH ST
5460 4TH ST
5460 4TH ST
5460 4TH ST
5460 4TH ST
5460 4TH ST
5460 4TH ST
5460 4TH ST
5460 4TH ST
5460 4TH ST
5460 4TH ST
5460 4TH ST
5460 4TH ST
5460 4TH ST
5460 4TH ST
5460 4TH ST
5460 4TH ST
5460 4TH ST
5460 4TH ST
5460 4TH ST
5460 4TH ST
5460 4TH ST
5460 4TH ST
5460 4TH ST
5460 4TH ST
5460 4TH ST
5460 4TH ST
5460 4TH ST
5460 4TH ST
5460 4TH ST
5460 4TH ST
5460 4TH ST
5460 4TH ST
VIEW PHOTOS
Courtesy of Kathryn Taillon with Lighthouse Realty Associates
$395,000

5460 4TH ST

3 Beds 2 Baths 1,256 Sq.Ft. 8,276.4 Sq.Ft.

Inquire Now

Description

Dream Home on Anastasia Island - Steps to Butler Beach! Discover coastal living at its best in this beautifully maintained single-story 3 bedroom, 2 bath home located just 0.3 miles from pristine Butler Beach. Nestled in a quiet, safe neighborhood on highly desirable Anastasia Island, this property offers comfort, upgrades, and unbeatable investment potential. This home boasts 1,260 sq. ft. of finished living space, plus a 238 sq. ft. screened-in porch and a 350 sq. ft. finished utility room perfect for hobbies, office, or storage. It has a recently remodeled kitchen and all newer appliances. Modern features include energy-efficient tankless hot water heater and newer interior HVAC. A large private fully-fenced backyard with room to add a small pool, fire pit, or garden retreat. Lot Size: 0.19 acres with mature landscaping, irrigation, and septic system in place. No HOA or CDD. Enjoy the best of St. Augustine beach-style living: Walk or bike to Butler Beach, restaurants, and island shops in minutes. And this property would make an excellent vacation rental (no permit needed) or long-term investment property with high demand for island homes with easy beach access. Whether you're looking for a primary residence, vacation home, or income property, this turnkey home checks all the boxes.

Share Property

Location

5460 4TH ST, St Augustine, FL 32080

Status

Sold

Date Sold

November 12, 2025
Kate Taillon

Kate Taillon

TITLE

Agent

PHONE

(864) 419-2516

EMAIL

[email protected]

CONTACT AGENT

Property Amenities

Interior
Appliances Microwave, Dryer, Dishwasher, Washer, Refrigerator, Range
Flooring Carpet, Tile
Total Bedrooms: 3
Full Bathrooms: 2
Other Interior Features Ceiling Fans
Area & Lot
Lot Area 8,276.4 Sq.Ft.
Living area 1,256 Sq.Ft.
MLS® ID 255154
Year Built 1973
High School Pedro Menendez
Middle School Gamble Rogers
Elementary School W. D. Hartley
Type Residential
Status Sold
Exterior
Stories 1
Heat type Central
Sewer Septic
Roof Shingle
Finance
Sales Price $395,000
Real Estate Tax $340 yearly

Active Listings

For Sale

1570-1590 Northwood Drive
$3,200,000

1570-1590 Northwood Drive, St Augustine, FL 32084

  • 2 BATHS
  • 2,024 Sq.Ft.

For Sale

9353 Old A1A
$1,950,000

9353 Old A1A, St Augustine, FL 32080

  • 4 BEDS
  • 4 BATHS
  • 3,615 Sq.Ft.

For Sale

5485 Atlantic Vw
$950,000

5485 Atlantic Vw, St Augustine, FL 32080

For Sale

169 Aspen Way (Pool Home)
$829,500

169 Aspen Way, Palm Coast, FL 32137

  • 3 BEDS
  • 2 BATHS
  • 2,341 Sq.Ft.

For Sale

5398 Soundview Ave (Pool Home)
$789,000

5398 Soundview Ave, St Augustine, FL 32080

  • 4 BEDS
  • 2 BATHS
  • 1,975 Sq.Ft.

For Sale

8550 S A1A #261
$769,000

8550 S A1A #261, St Augustine, FL 32080

  • 2 BEDS
  • 2 BATHS
  • 1,064 Sq.Ft.

For Sale

159 Southwind Circle (Pool Home)
$649,900

159 Southwind Circle (Pool Home), St Augustine, FL 32080

  • 4 BEDS
  • 2 BATHS
  • 1,944 Sq.Ft.

For Sale

8550 S A1A #208
$619,000

8550 S A1A #208, St Augustine, FL 32080

  • 2 BEDS
  • 3 BATHS
  • 1,064 Sq.Ft.

For Sale

15 Sea Park Dr
$609,000

15 Sea Park Dr, St Augustine, FL 32080

  • 3 BEDS
  • 2 BATHS
  • 1,779 Sq.Ft.
View All

Anastasia Island

One of the most popular places in the St. Augustine area's and for good reason.
Explore the Area

Work With Us

Lighthouse Realty has been in business in the St. Augustine area for over 30 years. We are open 7 days a week to provide you with the best real estate service in St Augustine.

Contact Us
Get in Touch
By providing your contact information to Lighthouse Realty, your personal information will be processed in accordance with Lighthouse Realty's Privacy Policy. By checking the box(es) below, you expressly consent to receive marketing or promotional real estate communication from Lighthouse Realty in the manner selected by you. For SMS text messages, message frequency varies. Message and data rates may apply. Consent is not a condition of purchase of any goods or services. You may opt out of receiving further communications from Lighthouse Realty at any time. To opt out of receiving SMS text messages, reply STOP to unsubscribe. SMS text messaging is subject to our Terms of Use.
Contact Details

LIGHTHOUSE REALTY

(904) 471-3400
[email protected]



5401 A1A SOUTH
ST. AUGUSTINE, FL 32080